A Survey of Christian Spirituality


Based on "A History of Christian Spirituality" (1981) by Urban T. Holmes III

Prepared for the "Developing Spirituality" seminar series held in Lowville United Church, Burlington, in 1985.

Redeveloped for online access in 2026 by Wayne Irwin.

Presenting a non-exhaustive survey of
the Emphases, Paths to God, Spiritual Goals, and Other Observations

of the various Periods, Schools, Mystics  and Exemplars across the arc of Christian History.


The Early Church



Judaism Prior to Christ

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship

New Testament Period

JOHN THE BAPTIST (info)

JESUS (info)

THE APOSTLE PAUL (info)

Quadrant: Balance (all four)

Paths to God

  • repentance
  • constant training like an athlete
  • accepting the cost of discipleship
  • purity of heart

Spiritual Goals

  • the mind of Christ
  • light in the midst of darkness
  • love (agapé)
  • logos (reason)

Other Observations

  • the spirituality of the New Testament people is not that of the Jewish intelligentsia; hence more emphasis on the heart than on the mind.

The Apostolic Fathers

BARNABAS (info)

  • martyred c. 61
  • trad. founder of the church in Cyprus

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • simplicity of heart and single-minded service
  • temperance, even of religious zeal
  • martyrdom

Spiritual Goals

  • knowledge of God (or Light)
  • assimilation into Christ (recapitulation)

Other Observations

  • the writings of the post-New Testament authors tend to be naïve until the sophisticated discourse of Irenaeus of Lyon.

ANTHONY the GREAT  (info)

Quadrant: Purification

Paths to God

  • living an ascetic life
  • absolute solitude

Spiritual Goals

  • overcoming inner affliction by prayer
  • refrain from esteeming this world and remember the next

Other Observations

  • In a vision where the whole world seemed covered with snares and traps. Anthony heard an inner voice declaring that humility was all that was needed for escape.

ATHANASIUS of ALEXANDRIA  (info)

  • c. 296/8 - 373
  • Theologian and Patriarch
  • Chief proponent of Trinitarianism

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • accepting Jesus as the Divine Son of God
  • holding to "the tradition, teaching, and faith proclaimed by the apostles and guarded by the fathers."

Spiritual Goals

  • holding to the concept of the Trinity in the sense that both the Son of God and the Holy Spirit are consubstantial with the Father.

Other Observations

  • Jesus Christ is fully God and fully human
  • against Arianism, he insists the Son is of the same essence (homoousios) as the Father
  • His famous line (paraphrased):
    “God became human so that humans might become divine.”

Monasticism

MACARIUS the ELDER  (info)

  • c. 300 - 390
  • Egyptian monk in the desert of Skete

Quadrant: Purification

Paths to God

  • withdrawal to the deert to face the severe life there as an alternative to martyrdom (anchoritism)
  • struggle against boredom and loss of purpose (against acedia)
  • the steady ascent up the ladder of perfection

Spiritual Goals

  • awakening to the Word of God

Other Observations

  • monastics were not "trying to pull themselves up by their  selves in order to hear the Word of God
  • two forms of ife existed:
    eremetial - life in solitude
    cenobitical - life in community from time to timer

The Cappadocians

BASIL of CAESAREA  (info)

  • c. 330 - 379
  • (hermit, 358 - 370)
    (bishop, 370 - 379

GREGORY of NAZIANZUS (info)

c. 329 - 389

(instrumental in establishing the Nicene faith in the First Council of Constantinople 381)

GREGORY of NYSSA (info)

c. 330 - 395

younger brother of Basil of Caesarea. A thinker and theologian of great originality and knowledge. Sometimes called "the Father of Christian Mysticism"

Quadrant: Purification


HERMAS  (info)

Quadrant: Purification

TATIAN  (info)

Quadrant: Purification

IGNATIUS of ANTIOCH  (info)

  • c. 35 - 107
  • 2nd or 3rd bishop of Antioch

Quadrant: Purification

IRENAEUS of LYON  (info)

  • c. 130 - 200
  • the first great Catholic theologian

Quadrant: Purification

Paths to God

  • the practice of goodness
  • erotic passion for union with God
  • sober excitement beyond self-control
  • working together with God (synergy)
  • engendering an inner quiet (hesychasm)

Spiritual Goals

  • growth in goodness
  • becoming like God

Other Observations

  • described as typifying "erudite monasticism"
  • Basil was the legislator. His friend Gregory was the port, and his brother Gregory as the spiritual master

The Alexandrian School

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship

The Early Middle Ages (500-1000)



XXX

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship


The High Middle Ages (1000 - 1300)



XXX

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship


The Late Middle Ages (1300 - 1500)



XXX

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship


The Modern Period (1500 - Present)



XXX

PHILO (info)

  • c. 20 B.C.E. - c. A.D. 50
    Jewish Hellenistic philosopher

Quadrant: Theology

Paths to God

  • poverty
  • interpreting Scripture allegorically

Spiritual Goals

  • mysticism
  • wisdom

Other Observations

  • grounded in synagogal worship